Resistance of mechanically densified and thermally post-treated pine sapwood to wood decay fungi

Abstract

This paper evaluated the density and biological resistance of pinewood samples modified with thermo-mechanical densification and thermal post-treatment. The samples were densified with 20 and 40% compression ratios at either 110 or 150 °C. The thermal post-treatment was then applied to the pine samples at 185 and 212 °C for 2 h. These samples were exposed to white-rot (Trametes versicolor) and brown-rot (Coniophora puteana) fungi for twelve weeks and the resulting mass loss was determined. In the densified samples, the effects of the compression ratio on T. versicolor-initiated mass loss and of the compression temperature on C. puteana-initiated mass loss were found to be significant. The mass loss was less in the samples compressed at 150 °C with the 40% ratio, while the highest mass loss was observed in the undensified samples. In the thermally post-treated samples, the resistance to both decay fungi was significantly increased with the increase of the treatment temperature. The mass loss in the thermally post-treated samples at 212 °C after T. versicolor and C. puteana fungi testing was reduced by 73 and 67%, respectively. However, the effect of the densification processes on decay resistance in the thermally post-treated samples was insignificant.

Introduction

Wood is a sustainable, non-toxic and recyclable natural material having high strength and an aesthetic appearance. Because of these superior characteristics, wood is popular and widely used in many areas. However, under suitable climatic conditions, wood is easily biodegradable and vulnerable to various organisms like fungi and insects [1, 2]. A number of methods have been developed to protect wooden materials against these biological factors. Chemical impregnation of wood is one of the most important of these. Nonetheless, the use of many of these chemical preservatives has been restricted in various European countries due to the environmental concerns [3, 4]. As a result, a number of new modification methods have recently been developed for wood protection.

Thermal treatment is a wood improvement and preservation process against biotic and abiotic factors [5]. Although the mechanical properties of wood are affected by the thermal treatment process [6], it provides some important improvements in wood properties including dimensional stability, hygroscopicity, and decay resistance [7,8,9]. Thermal treatments affect chemical factors required for the growth of fungi such as nitrogen, vitamins, minor metals and mineral elements [10]. With thermal treatment, wood becomes more resistant to fungi due to chemical modifications of the wood components of cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin [11,12,13]. On the other hand, thermal treatments reduce most of the mechanical strength properties of wood [14,15,16,17]. As a result of these undesired disadvantages, extensive commercial utilisation of thermally treated wood has been limited [18]. Through the modification of densification, many of the physical and mechanical properties of wood can be improved. The modification process of densification in wood is usually performed by compressing wood in a transverse direction. Additionally, wood material can be densified via the impregnation of various chemicals into the cell cavities of the wood.

The main problem occurring in wood densification via mechanical compression is that the compressed wood becomes dimensionally unstable [19,20,21,22]. Thus, when compressed/densified wood is exposed to high relative humidity or soaked in water, it returns to nearly its original pre-compression dimensions [23,24,25,26]. With the intent of providing dimensional stability to mechanically compressed wood, various densification processes, such as thermo-hygro-mechanical (THM) and viscoelastic thermal compression (VTC), in which steam and heat are combined, have been developed [27, 28]. Moreover, dimensional stability has been enhanced using thermal post-treatments applied to the compressed wood at a high temperature [26, 29,30,31].

In light of the knowledge available in the literature, the purpose of this study was to determine the decay resistance of pine sapwood samples modified with the combination of mechanical densification and thermal post-treatment against white-rot (Trametes versicolor) and brown-rot (Coniophora puteana) fungi. In addition, the density variations in the densified and thermally post-treated pine samples were also analysed.

Materials and methods

Wood material

For this study, randomly selected Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) wood, from a timber company in Düzce, Turkey, was used. The pine samples were cut in rough sizes from sapwood, in accordance with the study methodology. Sampling methods and general requirements as stated in TS 2470 [32] were complied with, and attention was paid to ensure that no rot, knots, cracks, or differences in colour or density were present in the samples. The samples were subjected to natural drying for four months until they reached approximately 12% moisture content. Then, prior to the densification treatment, the samples were cut in the draft dimensions given in Table 1.

Table 1 Dimensions of pine sapwood samples before densification

The samples were placed in a conditioning cabinet prior to densification and held at a relative humidity of 65 ± 3% and temperature of 20 ± 2 °C until a stable weight was achieved [33]. In order to avoid potential fluctuations in the moisture content, the samples were then put in plastic bags and stored until densification procedures were begun.

Densification and thermal post-treatment

The samples were thermo-mechanically densified with a hydraulic press machine having a capacity of 180 tons, pressure and temperature control capability, and a pressing tray with dimensions of 60 × 60 cm². The process of densification was carried out by applying four variations using two compression ratios (20 and 40%) and two temperatures (110 ± 5 and 150 ± 5 °C). The samples, after being placed on the lower tray in the pressing mechanism, were subjected to mild pressure. Heat was transferred to the samples through their contact with the heated upper and lower sections of the press tray and their internal temperature was monitored by a thermometer until the target temperature was reached. Afterwards, the samples were subjected to automatically controlled radial compression (60 mm/min loading speed). Metal rods placed at intervals on the pressing tray enabled the samples to achieve the desired 20 mm thickness. After being kept under pressure for 10 min, the samples were removed from the machine and allowed to cool to room temperature, during which time pressure of approximately 5 kg/cm² was applied to minimise any spring-back effects. To provide dimensional stability, the densified pine samples were thermally post-treated at 185 and 212 °C for 2 h. Thermal post-treatment was carried out under the protection of water vapour according to the process described in the Finnish ThermoWood Handbook [34] after which the densified and thermal-treated samples were cut into smaller samples according to both density and decay test standards.

Density test

The air-dry density of the samples was determined according to TS 2472 [35]. The samples (n = 6) were stored in a conditioning cabin at a temperature of 20 ± 2 °C and relative humidity of 65 ± 3%, until they reached a stable weight. In this condition, each sample (M) was weighed with a sensitivity of ±0.01 g. Dimensions (length, width, thickness) were measured with a vernier calliper (±0.01 mm sensitivity), and the volumes (V) were determined. The air-dry density (δ) was calculated using Eq. (1).

$$\delta {\kern 1pt} {\kern 1pt} ({\text{g}}/{\text{cm}}^{ 3} ) \, = M/V$$

(1)

Decay test

Decay tests were conducted in the Wood Preservation Laboratory of Düzce University according to TS 5563 EN 113 [36]. All test samples (n = 4) were dried at 60 °C for 24 h, weighed (M ₁), then sterilized by autoclaving at 100 ± 2 °C for 20 min. For the study, one white-rot fungus (Trametes versicolor (L: Fr.) Pilat. (FFPRI 1030)) and one brown-rot fungus (Coniophora puteana (Schum.: Fr.) P. Karst (Mad-15)) were used for determining the decay resistance of the samples. First of all, a 3.7% malt extract agar (MEA) medium was prepared for the test fungi. Then, treated and control samples were placed in the Petri dishes, with a feeder strip laid across the samples to foster growth of the mycelium on the samples. Following fungal exposure for 12 weeks in an incubator at 25 °C and 70% relative humidity, the wood samples were cleaned of the fungal mycelia. All samples were dried at 60 °C for 24 h to calculate the percentage of mass loss and then weighed (M ₂). The mass losses were calculated using Eq. (2).

$${\text{Mass loss (}}\% ) \, = (M_{ 1} {-}M_{ 2} ) \, /M_{ 1} \times { 1}00$$

(2)

Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis

Changes in the cell structure of samples exposed to T. versicolor were investigated using the FEI Quanta FEG 250 scanning electron microscope. Small wood samples with the dimensions of 8 × 8 × 8 mm³ (longitudinal × tangential × radial) were prepared for SEM analysis, and the wood sample surfaces were sputter coated with gold. Microscopic images at different magnifications were obtained from tangential and cross-sectional segments of the pine sapwood samples.

Statistical evaluation

Analysis of variance (ANOVA) tests were performed to determine the effect of densification and thermal post-treatment on the mass loss (in the samples exposed to T. versicolor and C. puteana) and on the density of the pine sapwood samples (0.05 significance level). Significant differences between the groups were compared using the Duncan test.

Results and discussion

ANOVA results of mass loss and density measurements of the densified and thermally post-treated pinewood samples are given in Table 2. The effects of densification and thermal treatment on mass loss and density were found to be statistically significant (P ≤ 0.05). Duncan test results conducted for multiple comparisons of the means of mass loss and density in densified and thermally post-treated pinewood are shown in Table 3.

Table 2 ANOVA (analysis of variance) results for mass loss and density

Table 3 The mean values of density and mass loss (T. versicolor and C. puteana-initiated) in densified and thermally post-treated pine sapwood samples

Density

Density of the samples increased after densification treatment depending on the compression ratio and compression temperature. Higher density values were obtained in the samples densified at higher compression ratios and lower compression temperatures. The highest density (0.914 g/cm³) was found in the samples compressed at the ratio of 40% at 110 °C, to which no thermal post-treatment was applied. The density of these samples increased at the ratio of 51% as compared to the control samples (Fig. 1). The density increases occurring after compression resulted from the fact that the samples became volumetrically smaller due to the reduction of their cavity volume. Previous studies showed that increases in density were higher in wood materials compressed at low temperature since the spring-back would be less, thus confirming the results of this study [26, 37]. However, other studies have shown that an increases in compression temperature caused further increase in density [38,39,40,41,42]. In the aforementioned studies, it can be said that the differences in the density increase due to the compression temperature are caused by the applied densification method. In this study and the study performed by Pelit et al. [26, 37], the wood samples were compressed at fixed rates through the use of metal stopping rods during the pressing phase. However, in other studies, wood materials are compressed at constant pressure without using stopping rods.

Fig. 1

Density changes in densified and thermally post-treated pinewood samples

After thermal post-treatment, the density of both control (undensified) and densified samples decreased. In particular, the density values of both control samples and the samples densified at a low compression ratio (20%) decreased as a result of the increase in temperature of the thermal treatment. The minimum density value (0.550 g/cm³) was identified in the undensified samples thermally treated at 212 °C. In the samples densified at the high compression ratio (40%), an increase of the thermal post-treatment temperature influenced density values positively (Table 3; Fig. 1). In the literature, it has been reported that thermal treatments at high temperature applied to densified wood significantly reduced the spring-back or set-recovery effect [20,21,22, 25, 29,30,31, 43, 44]. After thermal post-treatment, density increases in the pine samples densified at a high compression rate can be explained with the reported literature.

Decay resistance

The maximum mass loss (31.32%) in the pinewood samples exposed to T. versicolor was found in the undensified samples without thermal post-treatment. However, no statistical difference was observed between the mass loss in these samples and in the samples densified at a low (20%) compression rate (Table 3). The mass loss in the samples compressed at a high ratio (40%) was lower as well. An increase in the compression ratio caused the mass loss in the samples exposed to T. versicolor to decrease. Compression temperature had no significant effect on mass loss (Table 3). It was reported in study performed by Skyba et al. [45] that mass loss in the THM-densified samples were at a minimum level after the white-rot fungi test; however, the samples did not exhibit any improved resistance to the decay fungi as a result of the THM treatment. In addition, in previous studies on wood densification performed with different methods [i.e., thermo-mechanical (TM), THM, VTC] it was expressed that the densification process applied to various wood materials did not provide any protection against fungal decay [30, 40, 46, 47]. It was determined by SEM analysis that the destruction of the cell wall caused by T. versicolor in the highly compressed samples (Fig. 2c) was less than that of the control (Fig. 2a) samples. The fact that void volume (porosity) of the highly compressed samples was lower and their cell lumens were partially closed might have prevented T. versicolor from penetrating and growing in the cell. SEM analysis (Fig. 3) had confirmed this situation. Compared with the control samples (Fig. 3a), the hyphal extensions in tracheids and pits causing the decay were seen much less frequent in compressed samples (Fig. 3c). Similar findings were reported by Schwarze and Spycher [48], Skyba et al. [45], and Dubey [49]. In addition, the lowered porosity of the compressed wood, may have reduced the oxygen content necessary for the fungi to develop in the cells inhibited their activity [50]. Furthermore, according to SEM images (Fig. 2a, c), it was observed that cell wall destruction caused by T. versicolor occurred particularly in the earlywood region of the pine samples. In addition, the spring-back in the densified samples without thermal post-treatment stemmed from the relative humidity in their cell structure that occurred during the test and increased the void volume (porosity) of the samples (Fig. 2c). After thermal post-treatment, the mass loss in the samples exposed to T. versicolor were lower and the biological resistance of the samples increased significantly, depending on the increase in the treatment temperature. The minimum mass loss was obtained in the thermally post-treated samples at 212 °C (Table 3). T. versicolor-initiated destruction of the cell wall scarcely occurred in the samples thermally post-treated at 212 °C (Fig. 2b, d). Particularly in densified and thermally post-treated samples, it has been seen that the cell spaces and resin canal which allow the hyphal extensions to spread to the inner parts of the wood are almost completely closed (Fig. 2d). In addition, the analyses of tangential section of these samples show that the hyphal extensions in the tracheids have almost never occurred (Fig. 3d). Moreover, the statistical analysis showed that the densification processes had no significant effect on the mass loss of the samples thermally post-treated at 212 °C and exposed to T. versicolor (Table 3).

Fig. 2

SEM images of cross sections of pinewood samples exposed to T. versicolor: a control (undensified and without thermal treatment), b only thermally post-treated at 212 °C, c only 40% compressed at 110 °C, d 40% compressed at 110 °C and thermally post-treated at 212 °C

Fig. 3

SEM images of tangential sections of pinewood samples exposed to T. versicolor: a control (undensified and without thermal treatment), b only thermally post-treated at 212 °C, c only 40% compressed at 110 °C, d 40% compressed at 110 °C and thermally post-treated at 212 °C

After the C. puteana test, the highest mass loss (24.90%) was found in the control (undensified and without thermal treatment) samples. The densification process led to a slight decrease in C. puteana-originated mass loss. The effect of compression temperature on the existing mass loss was found to be more significant as compared to that of compression ratio (Table 3). After the C. puteana test, less mass loss resulted in the samples densified at the higher temperature (150 °C). In the thermally treated samples, C. puteana-originated mass loss was significantly decreased depending on increase in the treatment temperature. The minimum mass change measured after the tests was found in the samples thermally treated at 212 °C, as in the case of the T. versicolor test (Table 3). In previous studies, it was revealed that thermal treatment applied to wood at temperatures of 200 °C and over significantly decreased fungi-originated mass loss. It was also reported that decrease in mass loss was caused by the degradation of hemicellulose and cellulose, the main components of wood, and the condensation of lignin [51, 52]. Furthermore, the presence of moisture in the wood is necessary for the fungi to develop. Thus, as a result of the lowered values on the hygroscopicity index after thermal treatment, increased decay resistance has been observed in thermally treated wood [12]. C. puteana-originated mass loss significantly decreased in the densified and thermally post-treated samples at two different temperatures (185 and 212 °C). However, it was determined that the densification treatments had no impact on the increase of biological resistance in the samples thermally post-treated at either 185 or 212 °C. In other words, no statistically significant difference was found between the mass loss measured in the densified and thermally post-treated samples and in that measured in the undensified and thermally treated samples at the same temperature (Table 3). Bami and Mohebby [50] reported that results of soft-rot and brown-rot decay tests on combined hydro-thermo-mechanically modified (CHTM) poplar indicated increased fungal bioresistance; however, the hydrothermal treatment step played a much more important role in the increased bioresistance and reduction of fungal attack. In another study it was reported that resistance against fungal decay and soft-rotting micro-organisms increased in the Norway spruce samples to which thermo-mechanical densification and oil-heat treatment were applied, either separately or together, and the best results were achieved in the samples in which both densification and oil-heat treatment were applied together [53].

Conclusions

Density of pine sapwood samples increased in parallel with increase in the compression ratio. Regarding compression temperature, higher density was obtained in the samples compressed at 110 °C. After thermal post-treatment, the density decreased in all samples depending on the treatment temperature.

Mass loss was occurred in the samples exposed to T. versicolor and C. puteana, depending on densification and thermal post-treatment conditions. The highest mass loss was seen in the control samples. Less T. versicolor-originated mass loss resulted in the samples compressed at the higher ratio (40%), while less C. puteana-originated mass loss resulted in the samples compressed at the higher temperature (150 °C). The mass loss was reduced in the samples exposed to both decay fungi dependent on the increase in temperature of the thermal post-treatment. Decay resistance significantly increased, especially in the samples at 212 °C. The effect of the densification conditions on the increase in decay resistance of the thermally post-treated samples was insignificant.

The SEM analyses showed that the destruction of the cell wall caused by T. versicolor occurred mostly in the earlywood region and did not affect the latewood region as much. In the samples without thermal post-treatment, hyphal extensions in tracheids and destruction of the cell wall were more severe in the control samples as compared to the samples compressed at the high ratio (40%). Moreover, hyphal extensions and destruction of the cell wall were not observed almost in the thermally post-treated samples.