- Original Article
- Open Access
Effects of microwave pretreatment on drying of 50 mm-thickness Chinese fir lumber
Journal of Wood Science volume 67, Article number: 13 (2021)
Low permeability of wood causes problems during drying of timber. This study evaluated the effects of microwave (MW) pretreatment on the conventional drying behavior and mechanical damages of Chinese fir lumber. MW pretreatment of lumber was performed at applied MW energy of 43 kWh/m3, and then, the samples were dried in a laboratory drying kiln. The results showed that the drying rate was effectively increased after MW pretreatment. The moisture content (MC) deviation in thickness and residual stress indexes of MW-pretreated samples were significantly decreased in comparison with the control samples, and the appearance quality of wood samples was not clearly affected by the MW pretreatment. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) micrographs demonstrated that pit membranes were damaged after MW pretreatment, and the micro-cracks in radial section as well as detachments between ray parenchyma cells and tracheids were also observed. Consequently, new pathways for moisture migration during drying process were formed after MW pretreatment, which contributed to the improved permeability of Chinese fir lumber and decreased drying time.
Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata (Lamb.) Hook.) is one of the most important plantation species in China. It has been widely used in timber construction and manufacturing of bridge, boat, and furniture . However, the large proportion of heartwood and low permeability of Chinese fir causes problems during drying process, such as long drying times, high energy consumption, and a number of drying defects, which seriously restrict its high efficient utilization.
Wood permeability reflects the easiness with which a fluid moves inside the wood under a given pressure gradient. The wood permeability is influenced by the conditions of cell tissues, chemical components, and physical properties of wood, and conditions of cell tissues are the most important factors . In softwood, bordered pit is the primary structure that governs the permeability [3, 4]. Pit aspiration, pit occlusion with extractives, and pit incrustation are effective in reducing the capillary size of the pit pairs . Increasing the radius and the number of pit membrane openings can improve the permeability of wood; thus, making the wood easier to dry and impregnate . Furthermore, the fluid flow inside softwood includes three primary pathways. In longitudinal direction, fluid moves through the tracheid lumen, pit aperture, and pit membrane pores [4, 7, 8], while in the tangential direction, fluid flow is primarily through tracheids and intertracheid bordered pits [3, 8], and the ray tracheids are regarded as the main radial pathways [9, 10]. Therefore, it could be an effective way to facilitate fluid flow in different pathways to achieve good permeability improvement.
Microwave (MW) treatment is an effective method to increase wood permeability [11, 12]. The MW energy vaporizes the water in wood rapidly during the treatment and the increasing steam pressure causes varying degrees of damage to each cell tissue of wood. Pit membranes, ray cells, tyloses, and even main cell walls are ruptured to form new pathways for moisture migration, which lead to increased permeability and create favorable conditions for wood drying, wood functional improvement, and new material preparation [13, 14]. Different degrees of MW modification depend on the process conditions and MW process parameters. With the increase in MW energy, the wood permeability increases and mechanical properties decrease . Low degree of MW modification accelerates the drying rate and does not significantly affect the wood mechanical properties [15, 16]. Meanwhile, drying defects (surface and internal checks; collapse) are reduced with the decrease in drying stress [15, 17, 18]. The increased permeability makes moisture move faster during the drying process, ensuring that the evaporative front is maintained at the wood surface for a long time and moisture gradient is reduced in the thickness direction, thereby decreasing the drying stress. Therefore, MW pretreatment is a proven way to reduce the drying time and drying degradation of refractory wood. However, previous studies have usually concentrated on the MW pretreatment for rapid drying of hardwood; the MW pretreatment of softwood was seldom reported in literature.
In this study, Chinese fir lumber was treated with MW radiation before conventional drying. The effects of MW pretreatment on drying time, drying rate, drying quality, and moisture diffusion were investigated. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) observations were conducted to investigate the occurrence of mechanical damages of cell tissues of wood via MW pretreatment. The results can provide a theoretical and technical support for rapid drying and high-value utilization of Chinese fir.
Materials and methods
Chinese fir logs with 24 cm diameter at breast height were procured from Ya’an of Sichuan province, South-west part of China. The basic density and oven-dry density of this wood species were 0.33 g/cm3 and 0.37 g/cm3, respectively. Lumbers with dimensions of 900 mm (Length) × 90 mm (Width) × 50 mm (Thickness) were sawed from the heartwood region of these logs. Prior to MW pretreatment, all lumbers were cut off the ends and then divided into two groups with dimensions of 300 mm (Length) × 90 mm (Width) × 50 mm (Thickness). One group was used for MW pretreatment, while the other was used as the control group. During this process, 20 mm length specimens were cut as the moisture content (MC) test pieces from 900 mm lumber length direction in order to determine its initial MC. Both groups were also divided into quarter-sawn samples and flat-sawn samples. All the samples were stored in a freezer with a temperature of − 5 °C to prevent the moisture loss. The average initial MC of the samples before MW treatment ranged from 50 to 60%.
Continuous feeding MW equipment (Frequency: 915 MHz) (Manufacturer: Nanjing Sanle MW Co, WX20L-19 type) was used for wood MW pretreatment experiments (Fig. 1). The rated power of this equipment was 20 kW, and max cross-sectional dimensions of timber were 100 mm (Width) × 100 mm (Thickness). According to preliminary treatments, internal checks could occur in Chinese fir lumber when the applied MW energy per unit volume of wood was higher than 43 kWh/m3, and the mechanical properties of lumber could be significantly decreased. Therefore, the MW energy of 43 kWh/m3 was chosen for MW pretreatment of Chinese fir lumber in this study, with the aim to reduce drying time without decreasing the quality of dried lumbers. The corresponding parameters of MW power, processing time, and conveyor speed were set as 15 kW, 92 s and 1.3 m/min. In order to prevent the steam pressure inside the wood from leaking quickly along the longitudinal direction, the ends of samples were sealed with epoxy resin before the MW pretreatment. 20 replicas were considered for MW pretreatment, of which the half were quarter-sawn samples, while the other half were flat-sawn samples. The weights of the samples were measured to determine the moisture loss before and after MW pretreatment. The MC decrease after MW pretreatment ranged from 1.2 to 2.5%.
Following MW pretreatment, 12 wood samples (6 quarter-sawn samples; 6 flat-sawn samples) with their respective control pairs, totaling 24 samples were dried in a laboratory drying kiln (Type: HD74/TAII. Manufacturer: HILDEBRAND Co, LTD. Japan). The drying schedule is listed in Table 1. The preheating stage and the final treatment last for 10 and 6 h, respectively. 6 random samples (3 quarter-sawn samples; 3 flat-sawn samples) with their respective control pairs were selected to record the MC change during drying process.
The appearance quality of wood samples after drying was analyzed as per China National Standard (Drying quality of sawn timber, GB/T 6491-2012), which is similar to the quality testing method for kiln samples (Chapter 6) . Then, the test pieces were cut for measuring the final MC, MC deviation in thickness, and residual stress index. The cutting schematic of the samples is shown in Fig. 2.
Final MC was determined by oven-dry method using the specimens cut from each sample. As shown in Fig. 3a, the layered MC specimens were divided into thin slices in the thickness direction. The No. 1 and No. 5 slices were surface layers and No. 3 was the center layer. MC deviation in thickness ∆MCd (%) could be calculated using Eq. 1:
where MCc and MCs are the MC of center layer (No. 3) and the average MC of surface layers (No. 1 and No. 5) (%), respectively.
The residual stress index of lumber was determined using the prong test method. The cutting lines were drawn on the stress specimens, as shown in Fig. 3b. The stress specimens were cut into fork tooth shape after measuring S and L. All the prong specimens were equilibrated in room conditions for 24 h to obtain evenly distribution of MC throughout the specimens . Then, S1 value was measured and residual stress index Y (%) was calculated using Eq. 2:
where S and S1 are the width of the fork tooth before cutting and after room equalization (mm), respectively, and L is the length of fork tooth (mm).
Moisture diffusion analysis
The moisture diffusion coefficient represents the rate of moisture migration through wood. The following equation was used to describe the falling rate period (MC < fiber saturation point) in the drying process :
where MR is the fraction of moisture content (%), M and M0 are the moisture content at time t and time t = 0 (%), Me is equilibrium moisture content (%), A is a constant, k is the drying rate constant (s−1), and t is the drying time (s).
As shown in Eq. 3, a plot of lnMR versus t was obtained. The Fick's second law of diffusion was used to perform moisture diffusion analysis according to the linear relationship between lnMR and t. The moisture diffusion coefficient De (m2 s−1) was calculated using Eq. 4 :
where L is the thickness of wood sample (m) and the value of π is 3.14.
SEM observation of MW-pretreated wood
In order to investigate the occurrence of mechanical damages of cell tissues before and after MW pretreatment, several 6-mm cubes were cut from the MW-pretreated and control samples. Then, specimens with standard radial surface and tangential surface were prepared for image analysis under Scanning electron microscope (SEM, Hitachi S-4800 N, Tokyo, Japan) instrument. Pits, tracheids, and ray parenchyma cells were selected for primary analysis.
Results and discussion
Figure 4 depicts the conventional drying curves of Chinese fir lumber. The drying time of MW-pretreated samples was shorter than that of the control samples. When the MC reached 10%, the drying time of quarter-sawn and flat-sawn samples with MW pretreatment were decreased by 9.51% and 12.61%, respectively, compared to the control group. In addition, during the preheating stage, the wood samples absorbed moisture under high humidity conditions. The MC of MW-pretreated quarter-sawn and control samples were increased by 0.68% and 0.59%, while those of MW-pretreated flat-sawn and control samples were increased by 1.27 and 0.37%, respectively. The decreased drying time and increased moisture uptake indicate that the moisture migration during the drying process was accelerated after MW pretreatment.
Drying process can be divided into two stages, depending on whether the MC is above or below the fiber saturation point (FSP). The drying rate of wood samples in different drying stages is listed in Table 2. The results showed that MW pretreatment effectively increased the drying rate. In comparison with the control group, the drying rate (whole process) of quarter-sawn and flat-sawn samples with MW pretreatment were increased by 8.66 and 16.56%, respectively. Furthermore, the drying rate were increased in both stages, i.e., early stage (MC > FSP) and later stage (MC < FSP). Compared to the control samples, the drying rate in early stage and later stage of MW-pretreated quarter-sawn samples were increased by 45.14 and 11.50%, and those of flat-sawn samples were increased by 40.09 and 15.88%, accordingly. This phenomenon may be due to the MW pretreatment accelerated moisture migration during the drying process, ensuring that the evaporative front was maintained at the wood surface for a long time in early stage. While for control samples, the MC of surface layer dropped rapidly below the FSP, and the evaporative front quickly moved toward inside wood. The drying rate primarily depended on the moisture diffusion in surface layer which is much slower than free water movement. Consequently, the drying rate in early stage was greatly increased after MW treatment.
The MC and residual stress indexes of wood samples after conventional drying are listed in Table 3. The drying uniformity, MC deviation in thickness, and residual stress indexes of the MW-pretreated and control wood samples met the requirements of the 1st drying grade in accordance with China National Standard. During the drying process, the stress develops due to moisture content gradients and non-uniform shrinkage properties of the wood . The moisture gradient occurs because the moisture evaporating rate from wood surface is higher than that moving from inside wood to its surface . According to Table 3, MW pretreatment improved the moisture distribution in the thickness direction and decreased the drying stress. The MC deviation in the thickness and residual stress index of MW-pretreated quarter-sawn samples were decreased by 48.06 and 42.92%, respectively, in comparison with the control samples. Those indexes of MW-pretreated flat-sawn samples were decreased by 31.79 and 48.59%. Statistical analysis revealed that these differences were significant between the MW-pretreated and control samples. A greater moisture gradient was developed in the control groups in comparison to the MW-pretreated samples. The reasons could be that the MW pretreatment accelerated the moisture movement across the grain, which contribute to reduced moisture gradient, thereby decreasing the residual stress indexes after drying.
Table 4 shows the appearance quality of Chinese fir lumber after drying. The bow, crook, cup, twist, and internal check indexes of the MW-pretreated and control samples met the requirements of the 2nd grade in accordance with China National Standard. Statistical analysis revealed that there is no significant difference in the appearance quality between the MW-pretreated and control samples, except for twist between the MW-pretreated quarter-sawn and its control samples. The results indicate that the appearance quality of wood samples was not clearly impacted by the MW pretreatment.
Moisture diffusion analysis
During the later stage (MC < FSP) in conventional drying, there is no free water in the wood and the process of moisture migration is a diffusion behavior. To evaluate the effects of MW pretreatment on moisture diffusion, the moisture diffusion coefficient of the MW-pretreated and control samples was analyzed as displayed in Fig. 5. No significant difference was found both in the quarter-sawn and flat-sawn samples with related control samples. This suggested that the MW pretreatment on Chinese fir lumber is more effective in the early stage of drying than later.
The increase in drying rate may be due to high pressure generated from fast evaporation because of high-intensity MW radiation on wet wood. The high pressure resulted in the rupture of some elements in the wood , such as pit membranes, ray cells, and even main cells. Thus, new pathways for moisture migration were formed, leading to an increase in wood permeability, thereby improving drying efficiency of Chinese fir lumber. Several researchers have obtained similar conclusions. The permeability and drying rate of plantation eucalyptus were effectively increased because of damage of cell tissues caused by MW radiation . Zhang et al.  found that the MW treatment could significantly reduce the number of aspirated pits in larch wood. Pit membranes and the radial parenchyma were also ruptured which lead to increased moisture absorption and drying rate.
SEM images of MW-pretreated wood
The SEM images of MW-pretreated and control wood samples are displayed in Figs. 6 and 7. In general, the main pathways for tangential fluid flow in softwood are tracheids and intertracheid bordered pits, while the radial fluid flow occurs primarily through ray cells. Nevertheless, the pits of Chinese fir heartwood are usually covered with the amorphous material and most of the pit membranes are encrusted. Figure 6a, b shows that the bordered pits and cross-field pits of control samples were intact and mostly occluded, which severely hindered the migration of moisture. In MW-pretreated samples (Fig. 6c, d), fine fractures were visible on the pit membranes. Hence, the radius and number of pit membrane openings were increased, which led to a faster movement of moisture through the pits; thus, the permeability in tangential direction was improved.
The transient cell wall capillary network has a great influence on the fluid flow from cell to cell. Several micro-cracks were generated in the radial cell walls of longitudinal tracheids after MW pretreatment, and the cracks mostly originated from the both ends of cross-field pit apertures (Fig. 7c). According to Muzamal, the presence of cross-field pits in the cell walls resulted in stress concentration under steam pressure, and the resultant stress concentration promoted the formation of cracks in these regions . These micro-cracks would provide new capillaries for moisture diffusion and make moisture easier to move through cell wall to adjacent cell lumen. In addition, detachments between ray parenchyma cells and longitudinal tracheids also occurred (Fig. 7d), new pathways for moisture migration were created in the radial direction and the radial permeability was improved as well .
Overall, MW pretreatment improved the permeability of wood in tangential and radial directions by creating new pathways for moisture migration. Therefore, the drying time was shortened effectively. These damages are in agreement with reports from He et al. . Furthermore, the cited authors observed that this degree of MW treatment could significantly increase liquid permeability without much decrease in the mechanical properties.
MW pretreatment (applied MW energy: 43 kWh/m3) can be used for improving drying characteristics of Chinese fir lumber. Drying rate was effectively increased in conventional drying process. MW pretreatment is more effective during the early stage of drying; this stage involves the migration of free water in wood. The MC deviation in thickness and residual stress indexes of MW-pretreated samples were decreased significantly in comparison with the control samples, which can improve dimensional stability during the remanufacturing of the dried timber. The appearance quality of wood samples was not clearly impacted by the MW pretreatment. MW pretreatment damaged a part of pit membranes, radial cell walls of longitudinal tracheids, as well as separated the ray parenchyma cells and longitudinal tracheids, which makes moisture easier to move during wood drying. The new moisture pathways due to MW pretreatment were likely the primary causes of the improved permeability and decreased drying time.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
fiber saturation point
scanning electron microscope
- D e :
moisture diffusion coefficient
- L :
the length of fork tooth in prong test method the thickness of wood sample in diffusion coefficient calculation
- M :
the moisture content at time t
- M 0 :
the moisture content at time t = 0
- M e :
equilibrium moisture content
- MC c :
the MC of center layer
- MC s :
the average MC of surface layers
- MR :
the fraction of moisture content
- S :
the width of the fork tooth before cutting in prong test
- S 1 :
the width of the fork tooth after room equalization in prong test
- t :
the drying time
- Y :
residual stress index with prong test method
- ∆MC d :
moisture content deviation in thickness of lumber
Guo J, Guo XX, Xiao FM, Xiong CY, Yin YF (2018) Influences of provenance and rotation age on heartwood ratio, stem diameter and radial variation in tracheid dimension of cunninghamia lanceolata. Eur J Wood Wood Prod 76(2):669–677
Zhao YK, Bao FC (1998) Theoretical analysis on the relationship between softwood longitudinal permeability and its structure (in Chinese). Scientia Silvae Sinicae 34(4):88–95
Erickson HD (1970) Permeability of Southern Pine wood-a review. Wood Science 2(3):149–158
Petty JA (1970) Permeability and structure of the wood of sitka spruce. Proc R Soc Lond 175(1039):149–166
Flynn KA (1995) Review of the permeability, fluid flow, and anatomy of spruce (Picea Spp.). Wood fiber Sci 27(3):278–284
Bao FC, Lv JX (1992) A study on the principle of permeability control of wood (in Chinese). Scientia Silvae Sinicae 28(4):336–342
Bolton AJ, Petty JA (1977) Influence of critical point and solvent exchange drying on the gas permeability of conifer sapwood. Wood Science 9(4):187–193
Keith C, Chauret G (1988) Anatomical studies of CCA penetration associated with conventional (Tooth) and with micro (Needle) incising. Wood fiber Sci 20(2):197–208
Liese W, Bauch J (1967) On the closure of bordered pits in conifers. Wood Sci Technol 1(1):1–13
Liese W, Bauch J (1967) On anatomical causes of the refractory behavior of spruce and Douglas-fir. Wood Sci J 19(1):3–14
Torgovnikov G, Vinden P (2009) High-intensity microwave wood modification for increasing permeability. For Prod J 59(4):84–92
Liu HH, Wang QW, Lin Y, Jiang T, Cai YC (2005) Modification of larch wood by intensive microwave irradiation. J For Res 16(3):237–240
Vinden P, Torgovnikov G, Hann J (2011) Microwave modification of radiata pine railway sleepers for preservative treatment. Eur J Wood Wood Prod 69(2):271–279
Li XJ, Lu KY, Lin LY, Zhou YD, Cai ZY, Fu F (2010) Fundamental characteristics of microwave explosion pretreatment of wood I. Properties of temperature development. For Stud China 12(1):9–13
Torgovnikov G, Vinden P (2010) Microwave wood modification technology and its applications. For Prod J 60(2):173–182
Koiš V, Dömény J, Tippner J (2014) Microwave device for continuous modification of wood. BioResources 9(2):3025–3037
Harris GA, Torgovnikov G, Vinden P, Brodie GI, Shaginov A (2008) Microwave pretreatment of backsawn messmate boards to improve drying quality: part 1. Dry Technol 26(5):579–584
Balboni BM, Ozarska B, Garcia JN, Torgovnikov G (2018) Microwave treatment of eucalyptus macrorhyncha timber for reducing drying defects and its impact on physical and mechanical wood properties. Eur J Wood Wood Prod 76(3):861–870
Simpson WT (ed) (1991) Dry kiln operator’s manual. United States Department of Agriculture, Madison
Pratt GH, Coday AE, Maun KW (2010) Timber drying manual, 3rd edn. Bracknell, IHS BRE Press
Phoungchandang S, Tochip L, Srijesdaruk V (2008) White mulberry leaf drying by tray and heat pump dehumidified dryers. World J Agric Sci 4(5):844–851
Marinos-Kouris D, Maroulis Z (1995) Transport properties in the drying of solids. Handbook of Industrial Drying 2:113–159
Pang S (2007) Mathematical modeling of kiln drying of softwood timber: model development, validation, and practical application. Dry Technol 25(3):421–431
Keey RB, Langrish TAG, Walker JCF (2000) Kiln-drying of lumber. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg
Li XJ, Zhou YD, Yan YL, Cai ZY, Fu F (2010) A single cell model for pretreatment of wood by microwave explosion. Holzforschung 64(5):633–637
He X, Xiong XY, Xie J, Li YY, Wei YQ, Quan P, Mou QY, Li XJ (2017) Effect of microwave pretreatment on permeability and drying properties of wood. BioResources 12(2):3850–3863
Zhang YL, Jia K, Cai LP, Shi SQ (2013) Acceleration of moisture migration in larch wood through microwave pre-treatments. Dry Technol 31(6):666–671
Muzamal M, Gamstedt EK, Rasmuson A (2017) Mechanistic study of microstructural deformation and stress in steam-exploded softwood. Wood Sci Technol 51(3):447–462
Weng X, Zhou YD, Fu ZY, Gao X, Zhou F, Fu F (2020) Effects of microwave treatment on microstructure of chinese fir. Forests 11(7):772
He S, Lin LY, Fu F, Zhou YD, Fan MZ (2014) Microwave treatment for enhancing the liquid permeability of chinese fir. BioResources 9(2):1924–1938
The authors express our gratitude to Junfeng Hou, Zhiqiang Gao, and Zhengbin He for their assistance with this study.
This work was supported by National Key Research and Development Project of China [2016YFD0600701].
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Weng, X., Zhou, Y., Fu, Z. et al. Effects of microwave pretreatment on drying of 50 mm-thickness Chinese fir lumber. J Wood Sci 67, 13 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s10086-021-01942-2
- Microwave pretreatment
- Chinese fir
- Drying rate